We have just published our proposal for the “Call for Polemics” at Sepublica 2013 (ESWC). Check it out here!: http://www.oeg-upm.net/files/polemics/
The document critizices the actual semantic publishing practices and proposes a set of requirements that all authors should accomplish when submitting a research work. In the near future we would like to include examples from our environment (complete and incomplete) in order to illustrate our proposal.
If you wish to contribute with additional ideas/suggestions, please do it in this thread.